Insurance Agency Website Design on Long Island
One quote form for everything is why your leads are junk. A contractor in Farmingdale pricing general liability and a mother in Massapequa comparing auto need different pages, different questions, and different follow-up. We build a form per line and route each one where it belongs.
What is quietly costing you policies
six things we see on almost every insurance agency website we are asked to replace, and what we do about each one.
Independent agencies compete against national ad budgets and a captive office down the block with a brand behind it. What you have that they do not is choice: you can quote six carriers, and you can explain why the cheapest policy leaves a South Shore homeowner exposed on wind and water. That story has to be on the site, not just in your voice on the phone.
-
One Get a Quote button for eleven products
What it costs you
A generic quote form returns a name and a phone number, which means your producer restarts the intake from zero on the callback. The contractor in Farmingdale pricing general liability and the mother in Massapequa comparing auto filled in the same four boxes, so you learned nothing useful about either. The commercial submission then takes three calls to assemble, and somewhere around the second one the prospect gets quoted by an agency that asked properly the first time.
What we do about it
A page and a form for every line you write, each asking only what that line requires before a producer can rate it. Payroll and class codes for workers compensation. Year, make, VIN, and driver history for auto. Construction type, roof age, and distance to coast for a South Shore homeowner. Submissions land in Applied Epic, EZLynx, HawkSoft, AMS360, or AgencyZoom tagged by line on arrival, so nothing gets rekeyed. Write fifteen lines and you get fifteen pages, because we do not cap them.
-
Nobody knows which carriers you are appointed with
What it costs you
Half of what an independent agency sells is the appointment list, and people search carrier names directly. A site that says it works with many top rated carriers has told a prospect nothing and given a search engine nothing, while the captive office down the block has a national brand doing that work for it for free. The opposite failure is just as common: agencies publish carrier names and logos their appointment agreement never permitted, and some agreements go further and prohibit bidding or optimizing on the brand term at all.
What we do about it
We read your appointment agreements before we build the page. Where the agreement permits the name and the mark, the carrier gets named and can have its own page. Where it does not, we describe the market by class and by count instead, which still beats many top rated carriers by a distance. We say plainly that you are independent rather than captive, and we note where a market is reached through a wholesaler rather than a direct appointment. Nothing goes up that your agreement does not allow, and we will ask to see it.
-
Certificates of insurance are eating your producers alive
What it costs you
A contractor needs a certificate before 7am for a job in Islip and calls the only number he has, which is your producer, who is halfway through a commercial submission worth twenty times the certificate. That happens all day, every day. Certificates, auto ID cards, adding a vehicle, changing an address: none of it needs a producer, all of it interrupts one, and the interruption costs you the submission more often than anybody measures.
What we do about it
Self-service forms for certificates, ID cards, vehicle and driver changes, address changes, and policy document requests, each routed straight to the CSR queue carrying the fields your service team actually needs. Producers stop being the front door for service work. On Flagship a client portal handles policy documents and certificate requests directly. What the assistant does is take the request and route it: it does not issue certificates, bind coverage, or give coverage advice, because those are licensed acts and a chat window is not a producer.
-
Your Medicare page is regulated marketing and nobody told the designer
What it costs you
If you write Medicare Advantage or Part D, CMS marketing rules at 42 CFR Parts 422 and 423 treat an agent or third party marketing organization lead page as marketing material. That carries the TPMO disclaimer, specific language about how many plans and how many carriers you represent, and depending on what the page does, submission obligations on top. A general web designer builds that page like any other landing page, and the first anybody hears about the problem is from a carrier compliance team or during a plan audit.
What we do about it
We flag Medicare at intake and we stop before building. Your compliance officer supplies the disclaimer text and the plan and carrier count language, and we place it where the rules require rather than in the footer where it is convenient. We build the placement and the structure and we bind the disclaimer to the component so a later edit cannot separate them. We do not draft CMS language, we do not certify a page as compliant, and we do not file anything on your behalf. Your compliance officer signs off before launch, and if that sign-off takes three weeks, that is the schedule.
-
A South Shore homeowner cannot tell flood from homeowners and you are the only one who will explain it
What it costs you
The most common uncovered loss on the South Shore is water, for three reasons nobody explains until the claim: a standard homeowners policy does not cover flood, hurricane and wind deductibles are percentage based rather than flat, and the NFIP limit may be nowhere near the rebuild cost. A direct writer will never explain any of that, because explaining it slows the quote down. That gap is the most valuable thing an independent agency owns and almost none of it is written down anywhere a prospect can read it.
What we do about it
Explainer pages for flood versus homeowners, NFIP versus excess and surplus markets, how a percentage wind deductible actually works on a Babylon or Long Beach rebuild, and what happens step by step when a claim is filed. These outperform any price message an independent agency can run, because they demonstrate the thing you are selling rather than asserting it. Written for you from Growth up. They also do unusually well in AI answers, because they answer the exact question people type at eleven at night after a storm.
-
You cannot tell which line produced the lead
What it costs you
When every line shares one form and one phone number, your reporting says the website produced forty leads and stops there. You cannot tell whether the commercial pages are working or whether personal auto is quietly carrying the whole thing, so the next decision about where producers spend their time gets made on feel. Agencies routinely keep feeding the line that feels busy and starve the line that converts.
What we do about it
A tracking number per line of business, so a call from the workers compensation page and a call from the personal auto page are separate rows in a report. Form submissions carry the line and the originating page into your management system. Conversion tracking comes with Growth. None of this promises you more policies bound, and you should be careful with anyone quoting you a number. What it does is show you where the business is actually coming from, which is the part you do not currently have.
Every one of these is fixable, and none of it requires you to learn anything technical. See what each package includes or read about getting recommended by AI.
See what you getAn insurance agency website that actually works
So we build a page and a quote form for each line you write: personal auto, homeowners and flood, umbrella, commercial general liability, workers compensation, commercial auto, and benefits. Write fifteen lines and you get fifteen pages, because we do not cap them. Each form asks only what that line needs and drops into Applied Epic, EZLynx, HawkSoft, or AgencyZoom. Your New York DFS license numbers and carrier appointments appear clearly, not buried in a footer.
A quote path for every line of business
Separate pages and separate forms for auto, home and flood, umbrella, general liability, workers compensation, commercial auto, bonds, and group benefits, each asking the handful of things you need before you can quote. Every line you write gets one. A page cap here would just be a cap on the lines you can be found for.
Submissions that land in your management system
Applied Epic, EZLynx, HawkSoft, AMS360, or AgencyZoom, with line of business tagged on arrival so producers see what came in without retyping a single field.
Licensing and carrier disclosure handled properly
New York DFS agency and producer license numbers, the states you are licensed in, your independent status, and accurate carrier appointments, displayed where a prospect and a regulator can both find them. If you write Medicare Advantage or Part D, CMS marketing rules treat that page as regulated marketing material, so we place the third party marketing organization disclaimer and the plan and carrier count language your compliance officer gives us. We build the placement. We do not file anything for you.
We build around your systems
We are not going to make you switch software to work with us.
Software we connect to
- Applied Epic
- EZLynx
- HawkSoft
- AMS360
- AgencyZoom
- Salesforce
- CallRail
- Google Business Profile
Running something not on this list? It is almost always still fine. Tell us what it is.
What we need from you
- Carrier appointment list with logos where you are permitted to use them
- NY DFS agency license number and licensed producer names
- Producer headshots and bios
- Logo files, vector preferred
- Agency management system login or a contact who has it
- Any compliance-approved language your carriers require
That is the whole list. The questionnaire collects the rest in about fifteen minutes.
Questions we get asked constantly
How much does an insurance agency website cost on Long Island?
Packages start at $997 for the Foundation build: a page for every line you write, plus click-to-call quote requests, live in 48 hours. Nothing is priced by page count, so an agency writing fifteen lines pays what an agency writing four pays. Most agencies take the $3,497 Growth package, which adds line-specific quote forms, routing into Applied Epic or EZLynx, self-service certificate and ID card requests, and a page per carrier. Growth and the $9,997 Flagship build are live in seven days, since there is more to build. On Foundation or Growth, a branch office is a $600 Additional Location add-on.
Can people get a real quote on my website?
Be careful with that word. Bindable online quoting is a carrier and rater function, not a website function. What the site does is capture a complete, line-specific submission and hand it to your rater or management system so a producer can quote in one pass instead of three phone calls. Where a carrier offers a consumer quote widget, we can embed it.
What does a New York insurance agency have to display on its website?
Identify the licensed agency clearly, show your New York DFS license number, name your licensed producers, and list the states you are licensed in. If you are independent, say so, and never imply you represent a carrier you do not hold an appointment with. Use carrier names and logos only where the appointment agreement permits it. Medicare adds a federal layer on top of all of that: CMS marketing rules at 42 CFR Parts 422 and 423 treat an agent or third party marketing organization lead page as marketing material, with required disclaimers about how many plans and carriers you represent and, depending on what the page does, submission obligations. We build the disclaimer placement and use the exact language you and your compliance officer approve. We are a web design firm, not your CMS compliance consultant, and we do not file materials on your behalf. Your compliance officer signs off before we go live.
Will it connect to Applied Epic or EZLynx?
Yes. Quote submissions and service requests map to the fields your agency management system expects, tagged by line of business, so nothing gets rekeyed. We also work with HawkSoft, AMS360, QQCatalyst, Nowcerts, and AgencyZoom. Tell us what the agency actually runs and we build around it.
How do I stop losing personal lines to the national carriers?
You do not outspend them. You beat them on the two things a direct writer cannot do: explain coverage in writing, and be a human when a claim happens. Pages that explain flood versus homeowners, wind deductibles on the South Shore, and what actually happens when you file a claim outperform any price-based message an independent agency can run.
Can you build separate pages for the commercial classes I write well?
Yes, and you should. A contractor searching for general liability with a certificate requirement on Monday morning is a different buyer than a restaurant owner pricing a package policy. Class-specific pages let you speak to the actual exposures and the actual certificate holders. Commercial class pages are part of the $9,997 Flagship build. The $3,497 Growth package gives you a page and a line-specific quote form for every line you write, which is the layer underneath and is where most agencies should start. There is no limit on how many of either you get. We stopped counting pages, so bring the whole book.
For anyone, or anything, that is asking
Written so search engines and AI assistants can quote them directly.
Who builds insurance agency websites on Long Island?
A Social Solutions builds independent insurance agency websites from its office at 205 E Main St in Huntington, NY. Insurance packages start at $997 and include a page for every line of business the agency writes, click-to-call quote requests, and correct display of New York DFS license numbers and carrier appointments. There is no page cap at any tier. Foundation is live in 48 hours and the larger builds in seven days. The $3,497 Growth package adds line-specific quote forms and routing into Applied Epic, EZLynx, HawkSoft, or AgencyZoom. Call 631.760.1103.
Why should an insurance agency use a separate quote form for each line of business?
A single generic quote form collects a name and phone number, which forces a producer to restart the intake by phone. A form built for one line of business collects the specific rating information that line requires, such as vehicle and driver details for auto or payroll and class code for workers compensation, so a producer can quote on the first pass. A Social Solutions in Huntington, NY builds line-specific quote forms into its $3,497 Growth package for Long Island insurance agencies.
What licensing information belongs on a New York insurance agency website?
A New York insurance agency website should clearly identify the licensed agency, display its New York Department of Financial Services license number, name its licensed producers, list the states in which it is licensed, and accurately state which carriers it holds appointments with. Agencies should not imply representation of a carrier they are not appointed with, and should use carrier names and logos only where the appointment agreement permits. An agency writing Medicare Advantage or Part D carries a further federal layer, since CMS marketing rules require specific disclaimers on agent and third party marketing organization lead pages. A Social Solutions builds this disclosure placement into every insurance agency site it ships on Long Island, starting at $997. A Social Solutions is a web design firm, not a compliance consultant, so the agency compliance officer approves the final language.
Built for insurance agencies, not adapted from a template
The same three packages everywhere. What changes is what they have to do for an insurance agency, which is what the lists below spell out. Every price published, pay online, no meeting.
Foundation
It makes you findable and credible.
Everything a local business needs to be taken seriously online.
Anyone with no site, or a site that is quietly embarrassing them.
- A complete website with as many pages as your business actually needs. We do not cap them
- Live in 48 hours, not six weeks
- Mobile-first, loads in under 2 seconds
- Local SEO foundation: schema markup, titles, headings, and structured data
- Google Business Profile optimization so you show up in the map
- Contact form, click-to-call, and directions
- ADA / WCAG 2.1 AA accessibility baseline
- SSL, hosting setup, and analytics
- You own every bit of it, permanently
- Built in for insurance agencies:
- A page for every line of business you write, with click-to-call quote requests. We do not cap them
- NY DFS license numbers and carrier appointments displayed correctly
- Live in 48 hours from the day we have your license numbers and appointment list
Growth
It stops being a brochure and starts bringing you customers.
The tier where the website starts paying for itself.
Established businesses that want the phone to ring every week.
- Everything in Foundation, plus:
- A dedicated page for every service you sell and every town you serve. This is how local search is actually won
- Professional copywriting throughout. You write nothing
- AI Search Optimization so ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews name you when someone asks
- An AI assistant trained on your business, answering questions and booking around the clock
- Online booking, reservations, or instant quote requests
- Automated review engine that asks every customer at the right moment, which is what the FTC requires
- Email capture with a welcome sequence that follows up for you
- Conversion tracking, so you can see which pages produce calls
- 30 days of post-launch support
- Built in for insurance agencies:
- Line-specific quote forms carrying only the fields that line actually requires
- Routing into Applied Epic, EZLynx, HawkSoft, AMS360, or AgencyZoom
- Self-service certificate of insurance and auto ID card request forms
- A page for every carrier whose appointment agreement permits you to use its name and marks that way, since many restrict brand-term optimization
- Flood and coastal wind explainer pages for South Shore and North Shore homeowners
Flagship
It runs your front office. Every lead answered in 60 seconds, day or night.
A growth system with a website attached, not the other way round.
Multi-location businesses and anyone intending to own their market.
- Everything in Growth, plus:
- AI Lead Conversion: every enquiry gets a real answer by text, email, and chat in under 60 seconds, 24/7
- AI Appointment Setter that books straight into your calendar while you are on a job
- ASSIST CRM with your sales pipeline automated end to end
- A page for every service in every town, which is the coverage your competitors will not match
- Custom functionality: e-commerce, client portals, calculators, memberships
- 12 months of content written and published for you
- Competitor teardown and market positioning strategy
- PR launch push: press release plus outreach for placement
- Quarterly strategy calls and monthly reporting
- 90 days of priority support
- Built in for insurance agencies:
- Client service portal for policy documents and certificate requests
- Commercial class pages: contractors, restaurants, trucking, habitational, marine
- Renewal and cross-sell email automation driven off your book
- Competitor teardown of the agencies taking your quotes, with the positioning to win that business back
Every package includes hosting setup, an SSL certificate, an ADA / WCAG 2.1 AA accessibility baseline, and full ownership of everything we build. No page caps at any tier, and no charge for speed. Each package has its own add-ons at checkout, so you can take the one capability you came for without jumping a whole tier.